
Insurers have a strategic choice to make: Companies understand risks better than ever, but excluding risks only widens the insurance coverage gap. “That’s the choice,” says David Leibl, vice president of sustainability and corporate affairs with Wawanesa Insurance. He adds that there is a generational opportunity available today for insurers, “both in terms of a reputational standpoint for insurers, but also the market opportunity that comes from prevention,” he told those gathered for a recent Reuters Events presentation.
The comments were part of the November 2026 presentation, entitled From Reactive to Preventative: Building the Foundations for Climate Resilience.
“The traditional value proposition is you pay us and you hope you never need to talk to us. You don’t particularly trust us, but if something bad happens, we’re there for you,” he explains. “Can we reimagine the value proposition so that we are engaging at the front end, being true partners in prevention? Because that’s what the market is calling on us to do. It’s a rethinking of that traditional relationship.”

Jonathan Salter, global head of risk consulting with AXA XL, meanwhile says “insurance is most valuable when it converts knowledge about loss into action before the next event.” He adds that it will be interesting to see if artificial intelligence (AI) models will be better than the standard models being used to date.
“I think that’s the next area where we’ll see increased capabilities,” he says.
Leibl, however, points out that the “last mile” of climate resilience – that is, where actions are taken which actually make a difference to the outcome – isn’t better data or modelling, it’s in changing human behaviour.
Moving the needle: Incentives
Because a roof costs considerably more than a sump pump, panelists say they need to consider incentives, both at the insurer level, and at other levels, as well.
“We need to be talking to people about how things are going to fail and how we can help them. Then the follow-through has to be visible,” Salter says. “You need to have owners and actions and support the client along the way. As insurers, we need to have some kind of reward for clients at the end. It’s not just about identifying risks, it’s about (being) in partnership, helping clients make better decisions.”

More, the panelists add that if there are mitigation efforts undertaken, these should be captured as data. “It needs to be recognized in the CAT (catastrophe) model. It needs to be recognized in underwriting and pricing by the insurer. It needs to be considered in the portfolio risk, the reinsurance, the cost of capital. If you have a mitigation action but any of those steps break down? Then maybe the benefit doesn’t flow through and the incentives are off,” says Graham Hall, assistant vice president of climate risk and exposure analytics with the United Services Automobile Association (USAA). “There’s definitely more we could do to improve how we think about that.”
In three years, he adds that he hopes there will be more financing products in the market to help insureds make their homes more resilient.
Leibl similarly notes that government stakeholders also need to take a role and an interest in incentivizing different behaviours. “The things we’ve incentivized as insurers,” he points out (leak detection and sump pumps among them), “the capital cost of those per homeowner is not as significant as replacing your roof with a Class 4 shingle, for example. A $200 discount on your home premium may not be the financial incentive that’s going to help you with that purchase. It may still create an affordability barrier for you,” he says. “Other stakeholders need to come to the table.”
Hall also points out that there may be a fairness imperative to consider too, as the price of a new roof, for example, is borne by the homeowner directly, even though there are many beneficiaries of the purchase. Those beneficiaries can also include the insurer, the mortgage holder, the future owner or owners and their insurers and mortgage holders, as well.
“Is there a way we can come up with some kind of mechanism to provide financing or spread the cost out between those different actors who benefit?” he asks. “Is there a kind of financing mechanism that we can think about today to really incentivize behaviour, which might be being blocked today?”

Scott Christian, executive vice president of catastrophe analytics and advisory with Willis Re, meanwhile, also takes the discussion back to the insured. “We start there,” he says. “The people we insure are also accountable and we want to empower them to be accountable,” he says. “The best claim is the one we never have and that was never filed. That starts with the homeowner.” Whether the insured is covering the contents of a rental apartment or the value of a five-bedroom home, Christian adds that there needs to be an effort made to empower, give a sense of discipline and pride and ownership over the issue. “How do we ensure that those incentives are there, where people are looking proactively at reducing their risk?” he asks.
Community-level solutions
At the community level, new parametric solutions are another matter insurers are learning more about, as is the case in Wawanesa’s recent announcement about the creation of a parametric solution which helps a charity continue restoration work if a certain river rises beyond a predetermined level. “It’s a remarkably simple tool,” Leibl says. “We’ll learn a lot from this. The point is that this type of transaction can be lifted and implemented (elsewhere).”
He adds that insurers are learning that community level resilience is exceptionally challenging. (But necessary, Hall points out, as one member of the community fortifying their homes against wildfire, for example, doesn’t do a lot if neighbours aren’t doing the same.)
“You need many, many community-oriented solutions in aggregate, and what works in one community isn’t necessarily directly applicable to another. It’s very time-intensive to get community-led climate resilience done right and for insurers to find their place within that ecosystem,” Liebl says. “But we think there’s a model here that could certainly be adopted in other contexts. Parametric unlocks new doors and tries to create protection where there might not be immediate opportunities.”
Commercial considerations
Finally, in commercial insurance conversations, those gathered say there is more that needs to be done to help clients understand the total cost of risk – such that they undertake remedial and mitigating actions, even if these do not directly translate into reduced premiums.
“Prevention needs a business case, particularly when there’s been few claims,” Salter says. “A good claims history might reflect good controls, but it might also reflect a period without a severe event. We need to help by providing realistic scenarios that you can work through with clients to understand what the impact could be. Our engineering teams need to provide evidence. We need to lean on the data we’ve got in claims, and we need to help commercial clients build that business case for investment.”
He adds: “I don’t think we’ve been brilliant at helping clients understand how the market works.”
One challenge is that the payoff of resiliency investments often takes a number of years to come through in claims, if at all. “Prevention has a terrible marketing problem. When it works, absolutely nothing happens, and we can't get around that,” Leibl notes.
Hall also suggests that it may take governance structures which incentivise short-term actions, even if actual benefits do not pay off for a number of years down the line. “I think right now, we don’t necessarily have the structure set up to facilitate that type of behaviour,” he observes.
Those working with commercial clients are encouraged to consider helping the risk managers they are working with, to then in turn navigate their respective organizations.
“Resilience falls between functions,” Salter points out. “You need to connect those decisions and those stakeholders internally.” (He points out that a broker proposing a solution may not be in touch with those actually making operational decisions about resilience investments.) “I think we need to enable the risk manager to be able to navigate their organization and talk the language that gets everyone behind the investment.”
The conversation’s moderator, Vinita Jajware-Beatty, president and board chair of the Toronto Insurance Women’s Association, also points out that such matters often need to make their way to the board level. “We don’t have enough insurance professionals serving on corporate boards,” she adds.
As for when to bring up such discussions, the panelists say claims time will always be a good time to influence behaviours. “We’ve seen a real shift in awareness overall, unfortunately often for the wrong reasons – because catastrophes have rolled through areas of the country where they haven’t before. We are hoping this might drive greater uptake and that we can move towards implementation, but it’s that last mile gap that still persists,” Leibl points out.
“The claim is the moment of truth. It always has been, but it’s also the moment of opportunity to engage policyholders in meaningful dialogue around resilience. Never is the need for resilience more acutely known to the policyholder than after they’ve discovered a loss,” he adds. “It is incumbent on all of us to move that curve a little bit so that these discussions are happening before.”