The Ontario Superior Court of Justice has approved settlements totalling $12.375 million in two class actions against Aviva Insurance Company of Canada over denied business interruption coverage during the COVID-19 pandemic.

In its October 26, 2026, decision, the court approved a $6,862,724.50 settlement in the Matt McCallum action and a $5,512,275.50 settlement in the action brought by The Royal Canadian Legion, Victory Branch #317. It also approved class counsel's fees, honoraria for the representative plaintiffs and the distribution plan.

Business interruption claims dating back to 2020

Both actions arose from Aviva's denial of business interruption claims during the COVID-19 pandemic. The disputes concerned business income coverage under policies containing restricted access and negative publicity provisions, following government-mandated closures and other pandemic-related disruptions.

Filed in June 2020, both actions were certified as class proceedings. A trial scheduled for January 2026 was postponed while the parties pursued settlement discussions, resulting in an agreement on July 2, 2026.The settlements do not constitute an admission of liability by Aviva, and the court did not rule on whether the denied claims were covered under the policies.

Under the agreements, the claims against Aviva will be fully and finally resolved. The settlements do not constitute an admission of liability by the insurer.

Court finds settlements fair and reasonable

The court found the settlements fair, reasonable and in the best interests of class members. It noted that the agreements had been negotiated at arm's length, with the assistance of an experienced mediator and a case management judge.

No objections were received concerning the settlements themselves, although one class member apparently objected to the proposed honorarium for the representative plaintiff in the McCallum action.

Court approves 27.5% legal fees

Class counsel's agreements provided for contingency fees of 27.5% of the gross recovery, applicable when a settlement was reached after certification but before trial. The court approved the fee arrangements.

The court approved $1.54 million in legal fees and $118,426 in disbursements in the McCallum action, and $1.08 million in fees and $242,731 in disbursements in the Legion action, plus applicable taxes.

In approving the fees, the court noted that counsel had financed the litigation expenses and assumed the financial risks of the proceedings. It also pointed to Ontario case law under which contingency fees of up to 33% are presumed valid.

The court stressed the importance of maintaining an economic incentive for lawyers to pursue class actions. No class members objected to the fee requests.

Settlement funds distribution

The court also approved a $15,000 honorarium for each representative plaintiff, recognizing their involvement in the proceedings, including communicating with class members and participating in examinations for discovery. The amounts will be paid from the settlement funds.

The court approved a distribution plan under which the funds remaining after legal fees, honoraria and administrative expenses will be allocated proportionally among eligible class members who submit valid claims. The plan is intended to simplify the claims process and maximize the amounts available for distribution.