Group Insurance and Group Annuity Plans Advisor/Director, Corporate Development, AGA Benefit solutions
Contributing expert
Stay ahead!
Click a tag to get email alerts when we publish related content.
Sellers, think like a buyer: What I didn't know three years ago
Published on November 16, 2026
Three years ago, I wasn't thinking about selling the company I had co-founded in 2015. Then, in March 2023, everything changed. One shareholder wanted to slow down, and we needed to replace him. Shortly afterward, a second shareholder wanted to leave as well. I initially looked for new partners, but eventually a sale process got underway. I admit I wasn't particularly happy with how things were unfolding. That journey deserves a column of its own.
I knew my clients, my products and my team inside out. I had a rough idea of what my business was worth. But when a buyer started talking to me about earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA), I realized I was a novice.
Today, I evaluate brokerages for potential acquisitions. And I see that most owners are where I was: excellent brokers who don't know how a buyer looks at their business. Here are three lessons that could help them.
Lesson 1: Revenue or earnings—it all depends on size
Two valuation multiples are commonly used in the industry: the revenue multiple, applied to commissions, and the EBITDA multiple, applied to earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization.
The smaller the brokerage, the more likely it is to be valued based on commissions: its earnings depend largely on how much the owner pays themselves, and the buyer will integrate the clients into its own operations. The larger the brokerage, the more emphasis is placed on EBITDA, because the buyer is acquiring an established organization.
As a general rule, valuations typically range from 3 to 4 times revenue or 8 to 10 times EBITDA. A very large brokerage, however, can approach 15 times EBITDA. These benchmarks also fluctuate with the market: the current correction in valuation multiples will be the subject of my next column.
The risk is using the wrong benchmark to value your own business before negotiations begin. A brokerage generating $2 million in commissions with a 35% margin produces EBITDA of $700,000. At 10 times EBITDA, it's worth $7 million, or 3.5 times its commissions. But with a 20% margin, its value drops to just $4 million. An owner relying on the "3 to 4 times revenue" rule of thumb could enter negotiations with expectations as much as twice as high as the actual valuation.
Another surprise: buyers normalize earnings. They recalculate them as though someone else were running the brokerage: your salary is adjusted to reflect the cost of replacing you, personal expenses are removed, and one-time items are excluded. Because every dollar is multiplied, leaving $50,000 in personal expenses on the books can cost several hundred thousand dollars in business value.
And these adjustments aren't automatic. What the seller considers a personal expense, the buyer may view as a legitimate business expense. Normalizing earnings can become a negotiation in itself, which is why it's important to document every adjustment carefully.
Lesson 2: The multiple reflects risk
The multiple answers one question: will these earnings remain reliable once the owner is gone? The more reassuring the answer, the higher the multiple. The most influential factors are:
- Organic growth: New clients are worth more than increases in premiums alone.
- Retention: Loyal clients make earnings more predictable.
- Recurring revenue: In group insurance, every annual renewal gives clients an opportunity to shop around. Group retirement plan revenue does not depend on renewals. Because it is less exposed to client departures, it is valued even more highly.
- Concentration and owner dependency: A major client or an owner who personally controls all client relationships represents a risk that the buyer will factor into the price.
- Team and size: An identified succession plan and diversified earnings help increase the multiple.
Two brokerages with identical earnings can therefore receive vastly different offers. Be wary of the multiple a colleague claims to have obtained.
Lesson 3: The headline price isn't the cheque
The purchase price is usually divided into three components: the cash at closing, made in cash; an earn-out, made later based on performance; and sometimes an equity rollover.
The earn-out deserves a closer look. Consider a $5-million offer: $3.5 million at closing and $1.5 million over three years, provided the brokerage maintains its revenue and grows it by 5% annually. If revenue stagnates, the seller will receive only part of that amount; if the brokerage loses major clients, perhaps nothing. This allows the buyer to share the risk, while the seller can secure a higher price if they believe in the future of their brokerage.
Before signing, ask yourself what the earn-out is based on, who will control performance after the sale, what happens if the target is almost met, and how much of the purchase price depends on it. A slightly lower offer paid mostly in cash can sometimes be worth more.
And the choice of buyer can change everything. A buyer that also operates as a third-party administrator (TPA) can turn brokerage revenue alone into a combination of brokerage and administration revenue. If the earn-out takes these combined revenues into account, the same book of business can generate significantly more for the seller.
Finally, not everything can be measured in dollars. In my own transaction, the fact that my entire team could stay on was also a major consideration. That's not always the case: some buyers let part of the team go after the transaction to generate the savings that help finance their acquisition. It's a question worth asking directly before signing. Your own future matters just as much: what role will you have, who will you work with, how much will you be paid, and for how long?
Understanding how a buyer thinks
Looking back, I didn't need to become a valuation expert. I needed to understand how a buyer thinks. Now that I'm on the other side of the table, here are the questions a buyer asks when reviewing a brokerage's file:
- Are these earnings real? The buyer will look for clean financial statements, with personal expenses separated and adjustments documented.
- Will these earnings last? The buyer will want to know about retention, organic growth and the proportion of revenue generated by major clients.
- Can the brokerage operate without its owner? The buyer will examine who manages client relationships and whether a succession plan is in place.
- How much risk am I willing to take on? The answer will determine how much of the purchase price is paid in cash and how much is deferred through contingent payments.
- Does the seller believe in the plan? A seller who reinvests part of the proceeds in the buyer's shares and becomes a shareholder sends a powerful signal: they're betting on the future rather than simply cashing out.
An owner who asks these questions before the buyer does will come to the negotiating table better prepared and often secure a better price. However, there's one question the buyer won't ask on your behalf: How much will you have left after taxes? Preparing your business from a tax perspective well before a sale is another topic worthy of a future column.
Three years later, I have no regrets. It wasn't the scenario I had planned, but I'm genuinely happy with the choice I made.
Stay ahead!
Click a tag to get email alerts when we publish related content.